Tasas de aceptación de revistas académicas
Tasas de aceptación de revistas académicas revisadas por pares: una encuesta de literatura.
Acceptance rates of scholarly peer- reviewed journals: A literature survey
La tasa de aceptación de las revistas académicas es un criterio de selección importante para los autores que eligen dónde enviar sus manuscritos.
1. Introduction
An important feature of scholarly journals is that they only accept manuscripts for publishing via a process called peer review. The purpose of involving anonymous experts is to filter out scientifically correct manuscripts of novelty value, as well as help improve manuscripts with potential for publishing (Ware, 2008). The acceptance rate of top journals in some fields can be as low as around 5%, meaning that the vast majority of submissions are rejected. It is because of the scarcity of publication “slots” in such journals, that getting accepted in them is so valuable to academics in promoting their careers.
Several studies have shown that the acceptance rate is an important factor influencing the choice of journal (Frank, 1994; Tenopir et al., 2016). Most authors have at some stage in their careers experienced the frustration of getting a rejection decision, often after a delay of se- veral months. Submitting an article to a journal offering a realistic publication chance is thus crucial, but few journals openly advertise their acceptance rate. It is very difficult to find such information systematically collected for alternative journals in the same field. In practice authors often have to rely on word of mouth from colleagues.
In most journals a lot of manuscripts are rejected already in an early stage by the editor or the editorial office (“desk re- ject”), without even being sent out to peer reviewers for evaluation. Such manuscripts could be out of the subject scope for the journal, of substandard language and presentation, or of no scientific significance. Some highly selective journals even use pre-submission inquiries to filter out manuscripts not worth the effort of a full peer review.
Te puede interesar
Retos de los sistemas agrícolas alimentarios
Laura Gutiérrez - Sep 17, 2024Seminario de Estudiantes “Retos de los sistemas agrícolas alimentarios” “Conocimientos tradicionales para el Manejo Sostenible del suelo en Sierra de…
Procesos migratorios y dinámicas de exclusión en la frontera México-Estados Unidos
Laura Gutiérrez - Sep 17, 2024Introducción. Migraciones, fronteras y COVID-19 Guillermo Castillo Ramírez Instituto de Geografía, UNAM Martha Trujillo Macario Posgrado de Geografía, UNAM El…
Grupo de Trabajo El humor, la risa y las jerarquías
comecso - Sep 13, 2024Grupo de Trabajo El humor, la risa y las jerarquías Coords. Dr. Jorge Cadena-Roa y Dr. Mitl Maqueda Silva Ciclo…